Put your hope in the One who reigns over Caesar

Sermon for Trinity 23

Philippians 3:17-21  +  Matthew 22:15-22

The last time the 23^rd Sunday after Trinity showed up in our liturgical calendar was six years ago, on the Sunday before the midterm elections in our country. And here we are today, on the Sunday before the general election, hearing again the Scripture readings for the 23^rd Sunday after Trinity which turn our attention to our citizenship under “Caesar,” and to our greater citizenship in the kingdom of heaven. Even if you’re as tired as I am of thinking about the political realm, don’t tune out from the Word of God before us today, because your Lord Jesus Christ has something to say to us about it, and we dare not ignore Him.

First, let’s walk through the Gospel. It was Tuesday of Holy Week and the Pharisees and leaders of the Jews were preparing their case against Jesus to put Him to death. So they conspired together to trap Him in His words. Now, remember the political situation in Israel at that time. Rome had conquered Judea some 60 years before Jesus was born, at the time of Julius Caesar. Julius Caesar was such a popular figure that all future emperors of Rome after him were given the title “Caesar.” At the time of Jesus it was Tiberius Caesar who was in charge, and you see on your service insert a picture of the coin that bore his image. King Herod himself served under Caesar’s authority, so the fact that some Herodians were present when our Gospel takes place is relevant to what happened next.

The Pharisees had carefully crafted their question to Jesus, using flattery first and then presenting a yes or no trap question that could have derailed His ministry right then and there. Teacher, we know that you are truthful and that you teach the way of God in truth. You do not care what people think, for you do not pay attention to who they are. So tell us, what do you think? Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not? If He answers no, then they have Him for inciting rebellion against Caesar, and Herod’s officials are there to witness it. If He answers yes, then He has to spend His last few precious moments of teaching explaining it to His followers, who were angry at living under Roman rule and saw the Roman tax as an unjust burden that the people of God shouldn’t have to pay. Either way, He would end up being sidetracked away from His main message.

Jesus sees right through their trap and gives them the perfect response. “Why do you test me, you hypocrites? Show me the coin for paying the tax.” So they brought him a denarius. And he said to them, “Whose image is this, and whose inscription?” They said to him, “Caesar’s.” Then he said to them, “So give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and to God what belongs to God.” It wasn’t exactly a yes or a no. But who could argue with what He said? His answer made it possible for Him to stay “on message” and move on, without getting sidetracked on this final day of teaching before His crucifixion on Friday of that week.

You see, God does have something to say to the Christian about the Christian’s responsibility toward secular government. It’s important, but it’s certainly not the heart of the Gospel message, not nearly as urgent as Jesus’ warnings to repent of all sin and to put your trust in Him for eternal life, not nearly as important as the judgment Jesus was foretelling for those who rejected their God and Savior, not nearly as important as the sacrificial death Jesus was about to suffer for sinful mankind at the end of the week.

And so, instead of fleshing out, at that moment, God’s will regarding the believing Christian’s duty as a citizen of Caesar’s kingdom, Jesus saw to it that His apostles fleshed it out sufficiently in the rest of the New Testament writings, so that we, who have already been born again and made citizens of the kingdom of heaven through faith in the Gospel, might have His teaching on this topic without losing focus on the heart of the Gospel, which is repentance and faith in Christ Jesus to deliver us from sin, death, and the devil.

You heard the apostle Paul say something about this in today’s Epistle. He says, Our citizenship (that is, the Christian’s true citizenship) is in heaven, and we eagerly await a Savior from there, the Lord Jesus Christ, who will transform our lowly bodies, that they may be conformed to his glorious body, according to the power with which he is able to subject all things to himself. Our true King and Emperor is Jesus Himself, seated at the right hand of God, reigning supreme over every king, over every Caesar, over every earthly kingdom. Heaven is the true home of the Christian. We’re just passing through this life, in the world but not of the world, and whatever earthly citizenship we may have here is temporary and far inferior to that other citizenship, in which Paul writes that Christians have been made fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God, having been built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ Himself being the chief cornerstone.

But that doesn’t mean that our citizenship here on earth is unimportant or meaningless. Christ, the King of kings and Lord of lords, working through the acts and decisions of men, has appointed “Caesars” all over the earth and has commanded us to “give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar.” What does that mean?

First, who is Caesar? The Roman Caesars no longer exist. But “Caesar” is a reference to whatever secular authority God has placed a person under. The overarching authority that a single emperor used to have over everyone in a vast territory has now largely been diminished and spread out among various government officials and branches of government, each having its own scope of authority, with each nation having its own authorities and forms of government. So, for us, that means city government, county government, state government, and the federal government of the United States.

Now the question: What things belong to the various forms of “Caesar” where we live? Jesus said, give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar. Well, what things are those?

To Caesar belong honor and respect. Peter writes, Fear God. Honor the King. God would have His children honor the secular authorities. Honor begins in the heart and extends to our behavior. Now, “to honor” doesn’t mean to love or to like, necessarily. To honor certainly doesn’t mean to worship. And it doesn’t depend on how honorable Caesar may or may not be. Because it’s not about honoring the person. It’s about honoring the position of authority that God has established, and it’s about trusting in God’s good purposes in governing the events of this world, even through ungodly and wicked authorities, as has been the case throughout most of history.

To Caesar also belongs our conditional obedience. St. Paul writes in Romans 13, Whoever resists the authority resists the ordinance of God, and those who resist will bring judgment on themselves…And St. Peter writes, submit yourselves to every ordinance of man for the Lord’s sake, whether to the king as supreme, or to governors, as to those who are sent by him for the punishment of evildoers and for the praise of those who do good. God would have His children submit to or obey the authorities who are over us, but conditionally, only when they issue lawful orders, within their scope of authority, and only where their commands don’t conflict with God’s own commandments. So we pay our taxes, even if we don’t think they’re fair or just. We obey the laws of the land, even if we disagree with them. But we don’t obey blindly or unconditionally. When Caesar ordered the early Christians to worship Caesar or to offer incense to the gods of Rome, the faithful Christians rightly disobeyed Caesar, even though it meant they were tortured and put to death. We obey whenever we can obey in good conscience, because, as Peter writes, this is the will of God, that by doing good you may put to silence the ignorance of foolish men—as free, yet not using liberty as a cloak for vice, but as bondservants of God.

“Bondservants of God.” That’s what Jesus would have us remember when He says, Give to God what is God’s. What things belong to God? Everything you have belongs to God. Your very life belongs to God. Your heart does not belong to Caesar, but it does belong to God, along with loving God with your whole heart, soul, mind, and strength. Not only honor but worship belongs to God—not to the government. Faith and trust belong to God, not to the government. As the Psalm says, Do not put your trust in princes, nor in a son of man, in whom there is no help. But, on the other hand, Trust in the LORD with all your heart. And unconditional obedience belongs to God, even if you don’t understand why He commands what He does.

So, since God has placed us under the laws of the kingdom where we live, that means that He also allows Christians to use secular laws and public ordinances, to make contracts, to do business in this world, and even to serve in secular offices, as long as these things are done lawfully, without disobeying any of God’s commandments, and with love for our neighbor at all times.

He has even given His Christians a role (in this country, at least) in choosing our various Caesars—thinking not only of ourselves, but also of our neighbor’s good. He has given us the responsibility to evaluate the available candidates for office according to His Word and to vote, not for the Caesar who will be perfect, but for the Caesar who, of the available choices, will best conform to God’s will, as an authority under God’s authority, to vote for the Caesar who (as far as we can tell) will do the most good and the least amount of harm for our neighbor, according to God’s Word. And since intentionally killing our innocent neighbor is one of the greatest harms that can be done, abortion is one of the most clear-cut issues for the Christian, making it our duty, as citizens of the kingdom of heaven, to do everything in our power, as citizens of an earthly kingdom, to keep the more-pro-abortion candidates as far away from power as possible, and you know very well who they are in this year’s election.

Who will Caesar be for us after Tuesday’s election? I suspect that, in some cases, it won’t be altogether clear for a while, and that it’s going to get messy, and that you’ll have very angry people on both sides claiming that an election was stolen and possibly causing chaos like we’ve never seen before. Whatever happens, we’ll get through it together, as the citizens of the kingdom of heaven, with God’s almighty help. Make it your purpose to avoid violence, to avoid hatred, to avoid vitriol, and to avoid despair. Do your best to give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar. But above all, pray to the one who is above Caesar, and put all your hope in Christ, who reigns supreme over every Caesar, for the good of His beloved Church. Leave all things to God’s direction. And, as Paul writes, set your mind on things above, not on earthly things. For you died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God. When Christ who is our life appears, then you also will appear with Him in glory. Amen.