The claims that required vindication

Sermon for Judica – Lent 5

Hebrews 9:11-15  +  John 8:46-59

Vindicate me, O God, and plead my cause against an ungodly nation! That was the opening verse of today’s Introit, from Psalm 43. Vindicate me, O God! That’s the cry of a righteous man who has been unjustly accused of unrighteousness, of a truthful man who has wrongly been called a liar, of an innocent man who has been unjustly accused and judged and condemned as a criminal. It’s a plea to God, who sees the truth, to stand up for the one who is being falsely accused, to rescue him, to make him victorious over his accusers. Men may get it wrong. They may treat the just man unjustly. But in the end, God will sort it all out and see to it that the righteous are vindicated and that the unrighteous are condemned.

Now, if Christians who have been falsely accused can pray this Psalm—and we can!—how much more the Son of God when He is falsely accused! And that’s exactly what we see happening in today’s Gospel. This Gospel is a fitting preparation for Holy Week as Jesus’ bitter enemies, the Jewish leaders in Jerusalem, spoke to Him with utter hatred and contempt, falsely accusing Him of all sorts of things. Next week, we’ll watch Jesus being falsely accused before the Jewish Council and before Pontius Pilate on Good Friday, and we’ll marvel at His silence. But in today’s Gospel, which takes place several months before Holy Week, Jesus does not remain silent at all. In fact, He doubles down and makes even bolder claims before the unbelieving Jews—claims that would, eventually, get Him killed, claims that would, eventually, require vindication from God.

“Which one of you convicts me of sin? And if I am telling the truth, why do you not believe me?

The Pharisees and other unbelieving Jewish leaders had been scolding Jesus on this day for His teaching. They had been boasting about their lineage from Abraham. “How dare you claim that you are some kind of savior, that we need you, that you were sent from God? We’re Abraham’s children. We’re the chosen people of God, Jesus! You’re a nobody!” And yet not one of them could prove anything Jesus said to be untrue. No one could point to any sin He had committed. Everything He did proved that He was telling the truth, and yet they still refused to believe Him. Here He tells them why that’s the case: He who is from God hears God’s words. This is why you do not hear, because you are not from God.

In other words, God’s children listen to God’s Word. The fact that people refuse to listen to Jesus, refuse to believe in Him, proves that they are not God’s children. That’s an accusation from Jesus, and how much of our society, of our world, would be on the receiving end of such an accusation! “You won’t listen to God’s Word. You insist on making up your own truth, your own right and wrong, your own doctrines and beliefs, your own way of salvation. You who do this—you are not God’s children.” That’s the accusation Jesus made against the unbelieving Jews. It’s the same accusation He continues to make against the unbelievers of the world. And people today mostly react the same way the Jews did to that accusation:

The Jews answered and said to him, “Do we not rightly say that you are a Samaritan and that you have a demon?”

They mocked Jesus as a Samaritan, a half-breed, an outsider, a worshiper of a false god, and even possessed by the devil. The world does the same thing today. They hold up their own false version of God—sometimes, even their own version of Jesus!—as the true God and label Bible-believing Christians as the mean ones, as the intolerant ones, as the ones on the wrong side of history.

Jesus answered, “I do not have a demon, but I honor my Father, and you dishonor me. I do not seek my own glory; there is One who seeks it and who judges.”

Notice, Jesus doesn’t launch into a grand defense of His words or His ministry. He doesn’t dabble in philosophy or apologetics. He simply denies having a demon, and claims that He is honoring His Father. He even claims that God seeks honor for Him, for Jesus, and He threatens the unbelieving Jews, that God will judge the one who does not honor Jesus. Then He adds an astounding promise:

Truly, truly, I say to you, if anyone keeps my word, he will never see death.

Death comes for us all. Everyone knows that. Imagine hearing someone claim that their words were the key to avoiding death. Now, what does it mean to keep Jesus’ word? It means, first, to believe He is telling the truth about God, about Himself, about us, about right and wrong, and about the way of salvation from death, which is through faith in Him as the Conqueror of death, sent by God to save sinful human beings who are otherwise destined to die, and to suffer death forever. But it means more than believing it to be true. Keeping His word also means actually acknowledging and repenting of our sins, trusting in Him for the forgiveness of sins, and seeking to put His word into practice in how we think and speak and behave in this world. Those who keep His word will never see death, will never taste death. That’s not a promise that our bodies won’t give out. It’s a promise that, when they do, our souls will not experience even a moment of hell or of separation from God, but will go on living with the life that we have in Him even now, and that, one day, our bodies will be raised and perfected and joined back together with our souls.

But all that was too much for the Jewish leaders. Then the Jews said to him, “Now we know that you have a demon. Abraham died, and so did the prophets. And you say, ‘If anyone keeps my word, he will never taste death.’ Are you greater than our father Abraham, who died? And the prophets died. Who do you make yourself out to be?”

They just can’t believe. They can’t believe anyone would be so bold, to claim that He can keep people from dying. That’s even crazier than claiming that God created the universe in six natural day—which those Jews likely believed. But to them, Jesus’ words couldn’t possibly be true, because if they were, that would mean that He was greater than Abraham, greater than the prophets. It fact, it would mean that Jesus was truly sent by God, was the Lord of life and the Ruler over death. And they were not going to accept that.

Jesus answered, “If I honor myself, my honor is nothing. It is my Father who honors me, of whom you say that he is your God.

The Father had been honoring Jesus throughout His ministry, in every miracle Jesus performed, in every perfect outcome of everything Jesus said and did. That’s why we really need to take note during Holy Week next week, because during that Holy Week, some 2,000 years ago, for about three days, the Father would not publicly honor Jesus. Instead, He would allow Him to be utterly dishonored by men. Why? And would the Christ ever be vindicated? That will be our focus next week.

For now, Jesus just keeps doubling down on His claims. You do not know him; but I know him. If I were to say, ‘I do not know him,’ I would be a liar, like you. But I do know him and keep his word.” Not only does Jesus call His detractors, “liars” for claiming to know God when, in fact, they didn’t know Him, but He adds another claim, almost as a taunt. Your father Abraham was glad that he would see my day, and he saw it and rejoiced. Then the Jews said to him, “You are not yet fifty years old! And you have seen Abraham?” Jesus said to them, “Truly, truly I say to you, before Abraham was, I am.”

You know, there are many, many so-called Christians today who claim that Abraham never believed in Jesus, and, therefore, modern Jews will also be saved without believing in Jesus. But in this text Jesus proves them all to be liars. Abraham did believe in Jesus. He saw Jesus from afar and put his faith in Him and rejoiced in Him, the distant Seed of Abraham who would come and be a blessing to all nations. In fact, when Abraham encountered the LORD God, even back in Abraham’s day, the truth is, he encountered the person of Jesus, though not the Man Jesus, because, unlike the rest of us, Jesus existed before He was born. In fact, He existed before the universe was born, from the beginning, together with the Father and the Holy Spirit, Jesus is. Or as He puts it, “I AM.”

This is the One whom you worship, dear Christians. The LORD, the great I AM, the Seed of Abraham, the Son of God and the Son of Man. This is the One who confronted the unbelievers in Israel, who spoke the truth to them but was called a liar, who was righteous but who was branded as unrighteous, who was innocent, and yet who was, eventually, put to death. They couldn’t do it on that day, because, as John says, His hour had not yet come. But it would, and we’ll spend next week hearing about it in detail. The accusers and enemies and murderers of Christ would have their day. And Jesus cries out through the Psalmist, Vindicate me, O God, and plead my cause against an ungodly nation! For a few days, it would appear that the Father didn’t hear Jesus’ plea. But all that would change on the third day, when Christ’s vindication would come.

You, too, will be vindicated, eventually, against all the false accusations people make against you, against all the mistreatment of the world, against all the apparent victories of the devil, who has been pummeling and pummeling the true Christian Church on earth for a long time now. When you suffer unjustly, when you’re unjustly accused, when the world condemns you, when the devil comes for you, when death itself comes for you, don’t lose heart. Say, Vindicate me, O God, and plead my cause against an ungodly nation, against unjust persecution, against sin, death, and the power of the devil. And you’ll see. God will vindicate you, just as He vindicated His perfectly innocent Son, to whom you belong, because, unlike the unbelievers in our Gospel, you are children of God through faith in Christ Jesus. Amen.